This cheddar is just developing the nutty qualities of age, while retaining a soft texture and firm freshness. Try this with a hybrid beer style known as a lagered ale, originated in Germany with a style known as Kölsch. In Ontario, Beau's Lug-Tread offers with a delicate but flavourful malt character, a hint of sweetness and a bitter finish.
This works wonderfully with the a young(ish) creamy cheddar—it's a complementary match.